The old farm sat up off of the road near the crest of the hill. Cedars, wild plums, ash and hackberry had overtaken the yard surrounding the old homestead. Poison ivy vines grabbed and wound their way up the larger trees, and fallen branches choked with dead grass and thistle collected below. An old truck sat deteriorating to the side. The house itself sat abandoned back in this forest. Due to its isolation and the respect shown in this part of the state, it still retained most of its glass. The paint had dried up and blown away decades ago. A wind break of large cedars ran out the back of the place over the top of the hill and down along a fence separating the north and south crop fields.
The two brothers picked their way through the homestead lot hoping to push a rooster or quail out the back down the windbreak along the fence row. They picked their way carefully and stopped to listen often. The older boy carried a shotgun awkwardly, carefully pointing it away from his brother. They worked their way out the tangles in the back to the fence line.
This area was hilly and in wetter years the mud prohibited cultivation in the ditches of the small valleys and depressions formed by the hills; this provided islands of cover to small animals and birds. This year had been dry. The meticulous care shown the fields contrasted with the chaos and neglect inside the homestead plot. The lease farmer had expertly disked and harrowed down into every ditch and finger until nearly every inch of both fields had been planted. No cover remained on the fence lines.
Crossing the fence out the back of the homestead plot into the corn stubble field, they split up and followed either side of the cedars on the fence row. The cedars continued up to the crest and then down the hill towards the center of this section where dense reeds surrounded a pond. The boys stayed in the corn stubble on either side of the cedars, winding through and over the stalks working over the crest and down the hill to the pond. They watched for a rabbit to break. Their breath was clearly visible in the air. It had been cold for over a month, and while it hadn’t yet snowed, puddles and small ponds had frozen over. This day was humid and warming, a slight wind from the south and low dark clouds told of a coming snow. The older brother shifted the shotgun from hand to hand to keep his hands warm; the younger occasionally stopped to pick up and chuck a dirt clod up into the cedars on the fence.
The cedars ended down by the reeds on the pond. A small copse of leafless wild plums surrounded a large cottonwood in the swamp just beyond. As the boys neared the swamp, they exchanged glances and gestured to plan their approach. This little clump of trees and brush had harbored generations of pheasants long before they began hunting. Slowing, they picked and crouched along taking pains to move without noise. The older boy held his shotgun ready, anticipated a flush. He knew the sting of being jarred from a daydream by a flushing rooster.
The wind hid their approach perfectly. Nearly upon the reeds, they crept closer and stopped, waiting and watching. Glancing at each other, they waited and listened, mouths open. With a final look, the older boy nodded to his brother and they stepped into the brush.
The brush before them exploded with deer, white tails and long whistling snorts. The deer leaped and bounded escaping towards the pond flagging. The boys watched the deer retreat, hearts pounding. The deer entered the thick reeds and crashed through, dodging and careening into each other. The urgent clamor receded as the deer made their way up the side of the swamp along the pond still snorting.
They followed the deer’s progress up the swamp. The surge of adrenaline now abating, the boys looked at each other. The younger bent over, as if exhausted, and followed the noise resting his hands on his knees. They had never been this close to a deer before, let alone this many. They clearly hadn’t anticipated such a successful stalk.
Breaking ice and a splash brought their attention back to the present. They could hear an animal struggling in the water. The hollow, low splashing clearly communicated distress. The brothers glanced at each other, and began walking up the edge of the reeds towards the noise.
As they skirted the swamp it was clear the animal was struggling. The initial splashing had stopped, and every few moments would begin again. Periodically it stopped, and they halted to catch the thread again. It had been relatively distant at first. As they jogged up the edge of the reeds they wondered if it had really happened. The pond was obscured by the reeds down on the end where they had spooked the deer. Then the splashing would begin again and they jogged closer towards the struggle.
The reeds began to thin out and they glimpsed a dark shape out on the ice, it bobbed and ducked. It was a deer. They walked now to a spot closest to the deer on the edge of the pond. The older boy paused, then started into the reeds towards the deer.
‘What are you doing?’
‘I’m just going to see.’
The younger brother stayed back and watched as the boy held his shotgun up and stepped into the reeds on the frozen pond. He made it to the edge of the reeds, looked down to estimate the strength of the ice. It was cloudy and he decided to go no further.
The deer must have broken from the reeds and tried its escape over the pond. Several stumps stood up in the ice, remnants of the trees that had grown here prior to the placement of the earthen dam. The ice was rotten in places, this young deer had found one and fallen through. The deer was treading water. It held its mouth open panting. After a pause it surged flailing the water trying to gain the lip of the ice. It appeared it would make it, but the ice gave way in a sheet and the deer sank quickly back into the water.
The boy knelt by the edge of the reeds and watched the struggle. Only thirty yards separated them. He could clearly hear the labored breathing as the deer paced itself for its next attack on the lip of the ice. Each heavy breath the deer made was carried away by the breeze until it dissipated down wind. The boy could see the purpose in the deer, not panicked now. Its concentration focused on the task of climbing out of the ice, the boy could clearly see his presence was of no consequence to the deer.
The deer made another attempt. It surged, its chest and one foreleg cleared the lip, and it flailed only to catch under the lip with the other. It slid back into the water this time going completely under. When it resurfaced it blew and coughed. Its demeanor changed, now clearly panicked. It bobbed a couple of times, its head slipping further and further towards the surface of the water losing buoyancy. It pirouetted in the hole in the ice, struggled with the sheets and chunks of ice, looked for a possible way out of the trap.
The boy watched. He noticed his brother now at his side.
‘Is it going to make it?’
‘I don’t know.’
‘We should shoot it.’
The boy thought about that. The deer was losing now. It had been several minutes since its last attack on the ice. He was torn. This wasn’t deer season, he didn’t have a tag. He didn’t know what the law would say about him killing this deer. No one would probably ever find out. But, he only had bird shot. Even he knew it wouldn’t be effective and would only further pain the deer.
‘I’ve only got sevens. They would only wound it.’
‘But it’s suffering.’
‘I know it.’
They watched. Now the deer was barely keeping its head above the water. At times its head would bob under, it would surface and blow and cough. It rolled from side to side. Its coordination had left it, its eyes dull. It slipped down, head disappearing under the water. The body floated, buoyed up and its head stayed below. The boys stood for a better vantage, and the deer lifted it head and lurched once more, and sank. The water spilled out from the hole and spread out over the ice. The body of the deer was all that was visible now as the water in the hole quieted and became still.
The boy turned and left looking at the ground. His brother followed. They walked picking their way across the corn stubble, it dug into their shins as they teetered on the clods in the rows. Large cotton ball snowflakes began to fall as they made the crest of the hill and bee lined to the road north of the farmstead.



The Pursuit of Excellence
February 6, 2010When I was growing up, my family regarded both of my grandfathers as icons of excellence. I remember poring over pictures of my mother’s father after he died. His image was printed on racing programs, motorcycle advertising posters and Indianapolis 500 team photos. Aside from the family lore, I learned of his excellence after he had died as I investigated that stack of stuff he kept. It was there in one box in the attic. Of all the things acquired in life, this was what one man chose to keep.
You see, he wasn’t an excellent friend. His memorial service was one of the saddest I’ve ever attended, very few people were there. It was after the service when an older gentleman, one of his contemporaries, came up to my mother to express his condolences and sympathy. He pulled me aside afterward and told me my grandfather had gifts, he was one of the best. He repeated it, ‘The Best.’ My mother told me later that while he hadn’t always been the best father or grandfather, there were some people who valued his abilities and had overlooked his faults. I know he repeatedly broke my mother’s heart the last years of his life. He had selfishly withdrawn from her life, and from ours. This hurt her deeply. More than anything, I know she would have wanted us to know the good parts of him as she had. She couldn’t convince him. I searched those photographs to try to know him.
I never did really know or could understand his life looking through his things in that box, but did learn the value of excellence. Later I learned first hand how it is revered. I pursued excellence in sport in high school and later in the Air Force. I became an excellent runner, rifle shot and technician. I volunteered to deploy overseas and for positions of increasing responsibility on our jet. My single-minded pursuits paid off with trophies, awards and praise for my knowledge and ability. Enough, apparently, to fill an entire house.
Along the way I chose to not pursue or sustain friendships. Each time I made that choice on purpose. At times it just wasn’t convenient. Other times I held stubbornly to principle, or chose not to consider an alternate point of view. In all, I would say I authored the doctrine of a friendless life.
My father was visiting a few years ago. I had all my awards, plaques and trophies in a box in a closet. He must have gone through them. He told me I should put them up on the wall. I did, but I don’t know why really. It is impressive. It fills two walls in my office – which by the way is a bedroom. I’ve got a guest bedroom, it sits vacant most of the time. This house I live in is pretty big, and nice too. Though it’s filled with all kinds of my stuff, it is essentially empty. I know that.
People now ask me if I’m still shooting. I tell them I may. What they probably remember is the person that traveled to every rifle match within a day’s drive and shot in every meet he possibly could in pursuit of excellence. I can say in that pursuit, I have succeeded just as I have in most others. If I do pick up a rifle again I will have different goals. Though late, I have learned the second lesson my grandfather’s life had to teach me. It is more important to be an excellent friend.
Posted in Commentary | 1 Comment »